[Statement] We Condemn Hankook Ilbo for Fomenting Hatred of Undocumented Migrants!

Statement

한국어 / français / العربية / فارسی / русский / አማርኛ / မြန်မာ

Translated from Korean with AI. The Korean original prevails.

The Hankook Ilbo article of 4 February titled “Even with convicted murderers among them… the ‘bolt’ on immigration detention centres is about to simply come undone” (hereinafter “the article”) contains hatred grounded in prejudice and misunderstanding about undocumented migrants, and it urgently needs to be corrected.

The article states that “if the law is not amended by the end of May… a ‘legislative vacuum’ could arise in which immigration detention centres are temporarily abolished and the foreigners held there are released all at once,” and adds that “over the past five years, 152 foreigners were held long-term for 18 months or more, and 32.9% (50) of them were criminal offenders.” It then cites in detail cases of violent offenders provided by the Ministry of Justice, worrying that if things go on this way they will all be released and our society will be placed in grave danger.

As the article states, it is true that if the law is not amended by the end of May, the relevant provisions of the Immigration Act will immediately lose effect. This is because the current immigration detention centre system is an unconstitutional system that violates our Constitution. In March 2023 (the article wrongly gives “2022”), the Constitutional Court issued a “decision of constitutional nonconformity” on the provisions of the Immigration Act concerning immigration detention centres, stating explicitly as its reasons that the system excessively restricts foreigners’ “liberty of person” and also violates the “principle of due process.” Even so, the Ministry of Justice did not pursue an amendment of the Immigration Act and continued to detain people.

The article makes it look as though the bill is in danger of being scrapped through the fault of the National Assembly. However, the fact that the bill has not passed until this late stage is a situation that the Ministry of Justice either intended from the start or brought upon itself. Until the government introduced its bill on 7 October 2024, it did not open any forum for discussing the remedial legislation, such as a public hearing or a debate. It did not even seek the views of the relevant government bodies before introducing the bill, so the courts, the National Human Rights Commission and others who should have taken part in the discussion could not prepare for it. In the meantime, various lawmakers from both the ruling and opposition parties, including Rep. Park Ju-min, introduced bills in the National Assembly, but the Ministry of Justice only voiced its opposition and never put forward a concrete plan stating exactly what it would do and how. Civil society asked for discussion on several occasions but received no concrete answer from the government.

After staying out of the discussion for nearly two years, the Ministry of Justice, at a point when about seven months remained before the current law would lapse, put forward a bill with shocking content that is unprecedented anywhere in the world. The Ministry’s proposal would allow foreigners to be detained for up to 36 months without trial, and would even allow them to be re-detained without limit. As was also pointed out in the National Assembly, among the countries in the world that set a limit on immigration detention by law, the longest limit is 18 months. The related bills introduced in the National Assembly on several occasions over this period, regardless of party, all agreed that at a minimum a court should review any extension of detention. Realistically, it is hard to think of any way to meet the “procedure of control by an objective third party” that the Constitutional Court pointed to, other than using a court-based system similar to the existing warrants for the detention of persons. Yet the Ministry of Justice presented a novel bill under which a “Foreigner Protection Committee” set up inside the Ministry itself, an arrangement without precedent anywhere in the world, would conduct the review on its own, and this would count as an “objective review.” When a bill is proposed just before the deadline without any prior discussion, and its content is moreover so bizarre that a precedent is hard to find anywhere in the world, the discussion inevitably takes a long time. If the article meant to criticise the failure to amend the law in time, it should first have pointed to this conduct of the Ministry of Justice.

But if passage of this law is delayed further, will our society really become more dangerous, as the article fears? Immigration detention centres are not institutions that impose criminal punishment on foreigners who have committed crimes. Criminal proceedings against foreigners are the same as those against Korean nationals, and the criminal punishment of foreigners is also carried out by correctional facilities. If a person with a criminal record is in an immigration detention centre, it means that the person’s criminal punishment has already been fully completed. All that remains for this person is the departure procedure, and there is no particular reason to keep them waiting in an immigration detention centre. The statement “there are people with criminal records in immigration detention centres” is not itself false, but the bill whose passage the article urges has nothing to do with crime. This bill concerns the Immigration Act, and immigration detention centres are not correctional facilities but merely immigration enforcement bodies. These bodies have no function of crime prevention or correction, and legally they cannot take such considerations into account.

The Ministry of Justice is attempting to stigmatise migrants by bringing up the “criminal records” of a few people, which have nothing to do with the purpose or function of this law. Under current law, imposing the further disadvantage of restricting the liberty of people whose criminal punishment has already been fully completed would require enacting a new law, not the Immigration Act. Even if such a law were enacted, it would be hard for it to avoid being unconstitutional. So if the point of the article is that “it is a serious problem that we cannot impose further disadvantages on people with criminal records,” then what should be discussed is a constitutional amendment and new legislation for that purpose, not venting frustration on the blameless Immigration Act.

Reporting of this kind directly violates the Journalists Association of Korea’s Human Rights Reporting Guidelines, which state: “Do not use expressions that may cast migrant workers and others as potential criminals or as sources of infectious disease.” The Constitutional Court, too, stated in its decision on this law that “one cannot conclude that a foreigner who has committed a crime in the Republic of Korea will flee or commit a crime again if released from detention.” The reason an amendment of the Immigration Act is now being discussed is that the Constitutional Court ruled it “unconstitutional.” A government that had put in place no mechanism for carrying out deportation other than “tormenting people with indefinite detention” now finds itself having to devise a new system, and it appears to be trying to escape its predicament by stirring up hatred of foreigners.

This Hankook Ilbo article recalls the frenzied fear our society showed when Yemeni refugees arrived on Jeju in 2018. When some 500 Yemeni refugees entered the country, the media of the time reported hateful public opinion against refugees and Muslims without any filtering and made the situation even worse. Now, seven years later, none of the things that the forces fomenting hatred of refugees warned about at the time have happened. As if it had learned nothing from its past mistakes, Hankook Ilbo in this article again reports the Ministry of Justice’s claims without filtering and foments groundless fear of undocumented migrants. Hankook Ilbo must delete this article immediately and apologise in the name of its editorial board for publishing such an article as it stands. The apology should also cover its brazen use of the term “illegal sojourner,” which the United Nations recommends against using.