[Statement] We Welcome the National Human Rights Commission of Korea's Recommendation Finding Discriminatory the Ministry of Health and Welfare's Policy That Excluded Migrant Children from COVID-19 Emergency Disaster Relief Payments

Statement

한국어 / français / العربية / فارسی / русский / አማርኛ / မြန်မာ

Translated from Korean with AI. The Korean original prevails.

“Excerpt from the Commission’s Recommendation”

The recommendation of the National Human Rights Commission of Korea released this time (20진정0685301 and others) began with complaints from many organizations and individuals that the emergency support programs for children announced by the government in 2020 were discriminatory because they excluded migrant children. Children of foreign nationality had been excluded from the emergency disaster payment policies for preschool and school-age children announced by the Ministry of Health and Welfare and the Ministry of Education. Not only our network but also many teachers, who had seen firsthand the anti-educational effects of the discriminatory policy while teaching children in the field, are known to have filed complaints with the Commission asking for the policy to be changed. In response to the continued objections, the Ministry of Education reversed course and decided to pay the ‘remote-learning support payment’ to children of foreign nationality as well, but the Ministry of Health and Welfare still excluded many migrant children from eligibility for payments under the ‘Special Child Care Support Program’, so preschool migrant children could not receive the support.

Faced with a disaster that is ‘equal for all’, a government that stresses ‘everyone’s duty’ yet leaves migrants in crisis out of those eligible for support payments is a familiar sight to us. Migrants have been excluded from policies such as the ‘mask supply’ and the ‘disaster relief payments’, and they have also experienced policies that reinforce discrimination without any basis, such as ‘COVID-19 testing of all migrant workers’. The Special Child Care Support Program was no different. While claiming to pay support swiftly to relieve the economic burden on child-rearing households, it largely excluded from eligibility children of foreign nationality, whose economic burden must have grown because of COVID-19.

Migrant children’s households, too, face gaps in protection in a disaster, and the children are going through a period that matters for academic achievement; in this respect their situation is no different from that of children of Korean nationality. Indeed, considering that many migrant parents have only a narrow social safety net, are production workers who cannot work from home, and are not fluent in Korean, which makes it hard for them to actively support remote classes, the harm of the educational gap caused by COVID-19 may be even more devastating for migrant children. On top of this, the government’s policy, by implementing a discriminatory measure, stamped migrant children who are only beginning to form a sense of self with the stigma of being ‘a group that cannot receive equal educational support’, and is thus even anti-educational.

Yet international human rights law, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, and the Convention on the Rights of the Child, provides that educational opportunities must be offered equally to all children, and Korea’s Child Welfare Act likewise places on the state the duty to guarantee the welfare of all children regardless of nationality. The harm caused by COVID-19 is falling on all children and families in Korea, and migrant children and their families bear equally the duties and responsibilities that come with disaster response measures such as social distancing; excluding them from support meant to reduce that harm is therefore arbitrary discrimination. We call on the government to accept this recommendation of the Commission immediately and to provide the child care support that preschool migrant children and their families urgently need.

Meanwhile, this decision of the National Human Rights Commission of Korea is welcome in that it examined in detail the vulnerable situation of migrant children and their families and recommended that the government correct its disaster relief payment policy, but it leaves something to be desired in that it did not go as far as finding that a policy of not paying disaster relief to “children of foreign nationality” is in itself discriminatory and infringes on children’s fundamental rights, including the right to education. In the past, too, the Commission issued sweeping recommendations to correct local governments’ discriminatory disaster relief payments, yet it was reluctant to rule on the central government’s non-universal disaster relief payment policy. We hope that the National Human Rights Commission of Korea will speak out more actively for the human rights of migrants and the protection of migrant children’s rights in the future.